Idaho Dispatch

Your Local Media Ally

Op-Ed: Simpson, Fulcher Say Mayorkas Must Go

By • February 7, 2024

Idaho Congressman Russ Fulcher doesn’t watch much of the network newscasts, and generally he doesn’t think that he’s missing much. Since he lives and breathes congressional politics, Fulcher doesn’t need Lester Holt to tell him what’s happening on Capitol Hill.

But if Fulcher did watch the nightly news, he’d know that former President Trump doesn’t like the Senate’s bipartisan approach to the crisis at the southern border. Trump has been telling anyone with a microphone that the agreement would work in favor of Democrats in a presidential election year – and that is not good for Republicans.

None of that rings a bell with Fulcher, who spends many waking hours talking with his colleagues from both sides of the aisle about border security. But the Idaho Republican says that Trump’s name does not enter into the conversations, and he doesn’t need the former president to tell him that a bipartisan deal will be ashes if it gets to the House. House Speaker Mike Johnson has declared it as dead on arrival if it reaches the lower chamber.

House Republicans are going in a different direction – one that most likely will be dead on arrival if it gets to the Senate. They’re pushing for impeachment of Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, and it will take almost all House Republicans to push that through. Ironically, many of the House Republicans are the same ones who labeled two impeachments of Trump as “political theater.”

Indeed, impeachment proceedings against Mayorkas are great material – perhaps for the Cannes Film Festival. Fulcher acknowledges that the secretary’s ouster is unlikely, but he sees justification for impeachment.

Cabinet members, such as Mayorkas, serve at the pleasure of the president.

“But they are required to administer according to the constitutional law of the land, and that’s set by Congress,” Fulcher says. “Not only he (Mayorkas) has not done that, but he’s the guy who is saying that the border is secure. That’s absolutely not true by any metric.”

Fellow Idaho Congressman Mike Simpson agrees and raises the ante.

“For the last three years, our country has endured an unprecedented border crisis,” he says. “American families are suffering from the flood of fentanyl that’s entering our communities, border security agents are overwhelmed with that influx of migrant crossing the border, and human trafficking is worsening at an alarming rate. This is a direct result of Secretary Mayorkas willfully and systemically refusing to enforce the federal immigration laws. Secretary Mayorkas deserves to be held accountable for his negligence of our southern border.”

Again … Mayorkas isn’t going anywhere. If bad policy decisions were the standard for impeachment, we’d be without a president and a Congress. Simpson and Fulcher, who often come under fire for their actions, would be harvesting potatoes somewhere.

But as Fulcher sees it, impeachment proceedings – even if they are ultimately fruitless – send a message about the urgency of resolving the border crisis.

“The No. 1 concern that comes through my office is the open border,” Fulcher says. “The No. 1 failure of this Congress is that we have not been able to get it closed. You also could look at it the other way, and it’s also true, is that the No. 1 policy failure of the Biden administration is to keep it open. If they wanted it closed, they would have done it a long time ago.”

Fulcher says he has empathy for migrants and families who are looking for better lives and go through the legal process. But that’s not what’s coming across to the tune of 10,000 people per day.

“What we’ve been told through bipartisan channels is that we are spending approximately $150 billion a year on immigration, and that’s on health care and education,” Fulcher says. There’s also a cost for sex trafficking, human trafficking, fentanyl, the illegal drugs and the lawlessness that comes with it.”

More serious danger looms if Fulcher is right about what comes next.

“I believe in the bottom of my heart that we are going to have another 9/11 this year. That’s because of the bad entities that are coming through the southern border. I hope I’m wrong here.”

Amen to that.

Chuck Malloy is a long-time Idaho journalist and columnist. He may be reached at


This Op-Ed was submitted by Chuck Malloy. Op-Eds do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of those at the Idaho Dispatch.

Amazon Outlet

Tags: 2024 Presidential Election, Alejandro Mayorkas, Border Crisis, Border Crossing, Congressman Mike Simpson, Congressman Russ Fulcher, Donald Trump, Fentanyl, Homeland Security Secretary, Human Trafficking, illegal drugs, Immigration, Mayorkas, migrants, Sex Trafficking

4 thoughts on “Op-Ed: Simpson, Fulcher Say Mayorkas Must Go

  1. “If bad policy decisions were the standard for impeachment, we’d be without a president and a Congress.”

    Malloy – you really need to do better journalism. We have 8 MILLION illegals in our nation that Mayorkas is directly responsible for according to DHS and CBP. That’s human trafficking, sex slavery, drugs, weapons – ALL dangers to US citizens and ALL directly attributable to Mayorkas and the Democrats.

    And it isn’t “bad policy” its because he won’t follow existing law. And not only that, but he is refusing subpoenas from Congress regarding oversight. Those are all impeachable and prosecutable offenses.

    You present yourself as a journalist, but there’s more yellow than black and white where you are concerned. Time to step it up or retire.

  2. If a unanimous vote on the part of Democrats to not remove the DHS secretary for will dereliction of duty is somehow patriotic, I’d like to know why. As far as I am concerned, they and the three republicans that voted against Mayorkas’ impeachment are all traitors.

  3. Border protection has been a disaster for decades. I agree it has been exceptionally and tragically bad over the last few years, but let’s not pretend like both parties don’t have some accountability here.

    The [R]s keep losing and they can’t figure out why. They have lost their conservative principles and many attentive constituents.

    We have got to stop caving.

  4. Democrat’s support of Biden / Mayorkas open border policy is complete insanity and terrible for the future of our nation. The Rhino’s of the GOP are responsible with Dem’s. Until Rhino’s are removed with a president that supports closing the border, America will continue to lose.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *